Let’s Talk About Anal Sex

Top? Bottom? Versatile? How much does it REALLY matter?

Image for post
Image for post
Photo: pixabay/Olichel

In my recent MainlyMale article “Stop Shaming Me for Not Being ‘Top or Bottom’,” I explored the negative affect my general distaste for anal sex has had on my love life. Despite the side-eye and outright rejection I sometimes face because of it, gay men, even those who don’t consider themselves to be “versatile,” might be more flexible than I thought.

We included a survey with the story asking readers to share their own feelings about anal sex, and the results gave me hope. If, like me, you’re a guy who can take anal sex but would rather leave it, you’re not only not alone, but you’re in pretty decent company.

Tops down, bottoms up

First, we asked how you feel about anal sex, and a whopping majority of respondents said they’re into it. No surprise there.

Nearly 84 percent of the gay men who filled out the survey “really enjoy” anal sex. Of that number, 45 percent consider themselves to be “bottoms,” while 21 percent identify as “tops,” and 35 percent call themselves “versatile.”

The majority of men who left comments are “versatile,” and a number of them qualify their versatility as leaning more towards “bottom.” Some prefer their partners to be as open to switching positions as they are.

“Frustrated by guys who are fixed as tops or bottoms,” one person wrote.

Another expounded on that theme: “I’m versatile, though depending on my mood and the person I’m having sex with, sometimes all I want to do is bottom or I may want to top.

“Mainly I prefer to go with the flow, and prefer partners who do the same,” he continued. “So-called ‘top only’ and ‘bottom only’ guys make sex boring, which is why versatile guys are the best for me. I’m a strong believer in reciprocation during sex.”

A third wrote: “I would call myself a relationship bottom — I enjoy bottoming, but on a hook-up I find it very difficult to, well, let a guy in.”

The takeaway: The number of butt pics you might receive online from self-described (or implied) “hungry bottoms” on any given day tell only part of the story. There are a lot more “top” and “versatile” guys out there than Grindr might lead us to believe.

Can’t we just cuddle?

Interestingly, more men dislike anal sex than are indifferent to it. Of the 16 percent who don’t particularly enjoy going there, 10 percent “really don’t like it” and “avoid it when I can or always avoid it.” Only 6 percent don’t mind it but would rather do other things in bed.

“I have tried anal sex several times — both giving and receiving — and I know that it is definitely not for me,” one person revealed.

Hey 16 percenters, feel free to give me a shout if you ever spot me on the grid.

“I have tried anal sex several times — both giving and receiving — and I know that it is definitely not for me.”

As for anal sex or the lack of it becoming an issue in gay relationships, the threat, though not overwhelming, is real.

Image for post
Image for post
Photo: Wikimedia Commons/Nickjake876

We asked if your preferences regarding anal sex have ever affected your sex life/dating/relationships in a negative way.

A majority of guys — 59 percent — said no (lucky them!), while 26 percent said anal sex has gotten in the way of short- and long-term romantic bliss. And then there were 13 percent who claimed to be unsure. With so many other possible contributing factors to sex lives and love lives going bust, it must be hard for some to narrow it down to “Top or bottom?” — or “Can’t we just cuddle?”

“Some men just don’t understand that another gay man might not be into anal sex,” one person wrote. “I’ve missed out on a few dates because of this. They just can’t deal with it.”

Living in a “Top or bottom?” world

While some of us might cringe at “Top or bottom?” as an introductory line on Grindr (one respondent called it “rude” and decried the lack of a “versatile” option), it’s something that eventually needs to be addressed if things progress past the one-night-stand phase. It might be to gay men what “Do you want to have kids?” has long been to straight couples.

In the end, we can all acknowledge that sexual compatibility is important while understanding that sex doesn’t have to be about just one outcome. If you’re too focused on the penetration part, you may miss out on all the equally explosive things that can happen before, after, and besides anal sex.

“Please talk about hands-free cumming,” one commenter suggested.

Well, that would be an interesting start — er, finish.

Didn’t get to take the survey? Share your point of view in the comments.

Written by

Brother Son Husband Friend Loner Minimalist World Traveler. Author of “Is It True What They Say About Black Men?” and “Storms in Africa” https://rb.gy/3mthoj

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store